Best Toaster Oven Consumer Reports

Toaster ovens are the handy kitchen appliances that we all use daily. These units are compact, alternative to some bigger appliances such as standard toaster and air fryer, and don’t require much time to heat the stuff, especially on convection setting.

You can use them to toast the bread or to cook the full-sized chickens. The toaster ovens are also great to use in hot conditions as they don’t require preheating. According to some reports, the toaster ovens are energy savers and use up to 1/2 less energy than any other standard oven.

Best Toaster Oven Review | Top Rated

Here is the list of best toast oven available in the market.

#7 Breville Smart Oven Pro

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance
  • It comes with an oven light so that you can watch what’s happening inside the oven.
  • The toaster has ten different features to cook various items.
  • The capacity of the toaster is six slice toaster, 13 inches pizza.
  • Product measures around 18.5 x 14.5 x 11 inches
  • It comes with a built-in fan that circulates the air inside the oven
  • For quick and smooth cleaning, the inner walls of the oven have a nonstick coating

This Breville smart oven pro is enough for six slices of bread and a pizza. When you are looking for the best toaster oven, this Breville Smart is the answer. What makes it the best, let’s check out.
The Smart Oven Pro by Breville has excellent features for all types of food. Some common food types are sandwiches, cookies, pizzas, and chicken. By using these features, you can quickly and rightly set the time, temperature level, and cooking way (broil, toast, bake, warm, refrozen, slow cook) for all the toaster meals. The adjustment and settings are simple, so don’t worry about how you are going to use it. These features ensure precise settings as per your requirements and eliminate all the guesswork.
As for the heating, it uses an advanced Element IQ heating system. This advanced heating system effectively transfers the heat inside the oven for even heat distribution. The heating is quick, thanks to its 1,800 watts of power.
Some other handy functions of this toaster oven are interior light for quick monitoring inside the oven, a legend display, and a non-stick cavity inner wall coating that helps in cleaning.

What We Like!
  • Low energy consumption.
  • The controls of this oven are simple and versatile.
  • The overall construction of the unit is highly durable.
  • As the inner walls are nonstick, the cleaning is quick and effortless.
What We Didn’t Like!
  • The unit is not that suitable for beginners due to multiple settings.

#6 BLACK & DECKER Extra Wide Convection Countertop Toaster Oven

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance
  • It can accommodate 9”x13” pans, eight slices of bread, and 12” pizza.
  • Max Temperature of the oven is 450 Degrees.
  • It can accommodate all broiling and baking pans.
  • The inner side of this oven is larger than the others.
  • For even heating, it has a convection fan that circulates the hot in the oven.
  • For longer tasks, it comes with a 60-minute precision timer.

The Black Decker Convection Oven has many prominent features that make it exclusive and different from the other standard toaster ovens. One such feature is its convection fan function. Many users have appreciated this feature. This function allows it to deliver the best but noiseless performance; hence this Black Decker is quieter than the other models.
In addition to this convection fan feature, the Black Decker convection oven is praised by users for toasting, reheating, and maintaining the temperature of food. For your convenience, it comes with simple and easy to use controls with different settings for different types of food.
The interior light is another handy feature. The light will be on when the unit is working and shuts off automatically when it is not working. Some consumers also loved its 60-minute timer. According to consumer reviews, this timer comes handy in long baking tasks.
The interior of this oven is spacious, and you can put eight slices of bread or a 12-inch pizza. It’s extra-wide, so you can also put baking pans with handles.

What We Like!
  • The usage is simple as it features intuitive controls
  • Heating and processing time is excellent
  • The unit offers excellent value for your money
  • It comes with some handy accessories
What We Didn’t Like!
  • According to some users, the analogue controls are outdated and could have been better. But this also depends on your personal preferences.

#5 Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance

  • Spacious interior can accommodate 13″ pizza and 9″ x 13″ pan.
  • It has 15 different cooking features.
  • The oven includes digital controls with LED buttons and auto-slide out rack.
  • Distributes the heat evenly throughout the oven. It also features an Interior light.
  • The Dimensions of the oven are 20.87″ L x 16.93″ W x 11.42″ H

There are many things that we like about this Cuisinart convection toaster oven. The first thing is its spacious interior and large capacity. It can comfortably accommodate a 13-inch pizza or a pan with its handle. The unit itself is compact, so it will not acquire much space on your kitchen countertop. As for the settings and functions, the unit is capable of showing the full range of menu options, including cooking functions and convection settings.
The processing time and heating efficiency are up to the mark. We didn’t find any issues related to uneven heating or similar. The power is 1800 watts so it can toast or heat quickly.
It also features internal temperature compensation technology, which can tell the perfect cooking time as per the number of toasts. Heating the food is a breeze with this toaster oven as it features a speed convection button, which allows you to heat the food immediately.

What We Like!
  • Toasts and heats quickly as compared to other ovens.
  • Apart from heating, the oven is also excellent for broiling.
  • You can wash some parts of this device in a Dishwasher.
  • For your ease of use, it comes with an automatic sliding rack.
  • Multiple cooking functions
What We Didn’t Like!
  • The unit becomes too hot, especially if you are using it for longer baking tasks.

#4 Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance
  • The oven includes double Infrared Heating Efficiency to distribute the heat evenly.
  • It comes with a manual touch-button temperature sensor
  • It also consists of a small see-through door
  • This oven is a perfect match for your kitchen countertop due to its compact and attractive design.
  • FlashXpress Toaster comes with an inner tray
  • It can accommodate a 9 Inch Pizza or four Slices of Bread
  • The oven also contains Removable Crumb Tray

Due to its compact size, this 4-slice Panasonic toaster oven is a great option for small families. It can comfortably accommodate food for a few people.
However, the quality and performance are not less than the best. The unit works in a simple manner, and it is suitable for small heating tasks such as toaster stuff, like toasting and reheating. We will never recommend it for long baking or heating tasks due to its limited capabilities.
While reviewing the consumer reports, we found out that this oven toaster is simple and easy to use. Almost all the users also appreciate the heating efficiency. It can heat the food evenly from both sides and quickly.
Unlike other toaster ovens, this Panasonic FlashXpress utilizes both quartz and ceramic heating elements, which delivers instant heating. In simple words, you will not have to wait for heating; just turn it on, adjust the temperature to your desired level, put in the food, and it will start working instantly.
The cleaning is simple as well, take a soft wet fabric and wipe it properly. Due to its compact size, the unit is simple to clean.

What We Like!
  • Super-fast heating and cooking
  • The interior includes a working light
  • The overall construction of the oven is highly durable
  • The small size makes the unit simple to clean
What We Didn’t Like!
  • There is no undo option! Yes, you heard you cannot move back or cancel it is in working mode. You will be stuck in working mode till it completes the job. So, plan, prepare and then press the button.

#3 KitchenAid 12″ Convection Bake Digital Countertop Oven

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance
  • This KitchenAid oven can bake or heat 12-inch Pizza, broil a side dish, toast bread slices, or you can use it to heat the cooked items.
  • This KitchenAid digital oven comes with nine different functions, including Roast, Bake, Bagel, Broil, Cookie, Reheat, Keep Warm, Pizza, and Toast.
  • It can also broil the baked pasta or toast six slices of bread at the same time.
  • It allows you to set a 60-minute timer.
  • This unit is backed with a 1-Year Hassle-Free Replacement Warranty.

A KitchenAid digital toaster oven can be a lovely addition to your kitchen. The unit can toast six slices of bread at a time. The consumer reviews and feedbacks regarding this model are outstanding, and obviously, it is included in this list after getting excellent results in quality tests.
It is a perfect toaster oven if you are living in a joint family system, you have a large family, or you like to throw parties for all your friends.
After buying this KitchenAid 12-inch digital oven, you can easily and quickly defrost foods, heating the other food items, or you can even broil the baked pasta. Furthermore, there are separate settings for your favourite pizza and bagel.
For long baking tasks, it comes with a handy 60-minute timer, which will remind you when the food is ready. The nine different functions and settings will allow you to use it for many food items. It also features a convection option. This model features a single rack option, and its maximum temperature is 450° F.

What We Like!
  • An excellent alternative to the standard Ovens
  • It includes nine different Pre-programmed Functions.
  • The controls and settings of this oven are simple, even for beginners.
  • It features Even-heat Technology
What We Didn’t Like!
  • There are consumer complaints that the unit gets heated quickly.
  • No product manual included in the pack.

#2 COSORI Toaster Oven

Price at Amazon!

  • According to consumer reports, this oven is the easiest to clean. You can clean it just with a moist mop.
  • Features Elegant brushed stainless steel shell, a nonstick interior, and a beautiful glass door.
  • LED shows clear readings. Time and temperature are also visible on the LED.
  • The oven includes some additional accessories as well, like food tray, wire rack, crumb tray, and air fryer basket.
  • One-year official warranty by makers.
[/su_box]

This Cosori toaster over is the latest addition in the Cosori line up. The product is designed in the USA by a popular brand.
During our testing, the model performed very well. The results were satisfactory in terms of both quality and speed. The unit features twelve different settings for cooking. These settings are Toast, Pizza, Bagel, Bake, Ferment, Dehydrate, Air fry, Roast, Cookies, Broil, Rotisserie, and Keep Warm.
This toaster also features as Air fry feature with a convection fan. So, you can cook the food without or less oil. This is something that you will not find in most of the ovens.
The interior of this Cosori Toaster Oven is quite spacious. It can comfortably accommodate six slices of bread, a 13-inch pizza, or 5 pounds chicken. It has the ability to prepare food for seven people at a time. And that makes it perfect for large families and parties.

What We Like!
  • Twelve different settings for cooking.
  • A 1-year warranty backs it.
  • The setup and features of this toaster oven are simple.
  • It can cook food for seven persons at once.
  • The best toaster oven for parties and large families.
What We Didn’t Like!
  • The included rack is flimsy. Not suitable for heavy items.

#1 Vestaware Convection Toaster Oven

Price at Amazon!

Features at a glance
  • It includes a beautiful pull-down glass door with a visible window to see inside.
  • This toaster oven includes a baking rack, helper handle, crumb tray, grill tray, and rack clamp.
  • Operate it with a press button. The press start/stop button ensures precise temperature and time control.
  • This toaster oven has ten cooking features, including Defrost, Reheat, Toast, Bake, Broil, Pizza, Cookies,
  • Rotisserie, Keep Warm, or Convection.

During our testing process, we did not find any issues with this Vestaware Convection Toaster Oven. The overall working and performance of this toaster were excellent. It comes with ten cooking functions like Toast, Defrost, Reheat, Bake, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, Rotisserie, and Keep Warm.
Another remarkable feature of this toaster oven is its control knob. This simple yet handy knob allows you to control the entire unit. The settings and readings are displayed on the LCD, which is quite clear and easy to read.
The interior is large enough to accommodate a full chicken, a 10-inch pizza, 1and 6 slices of bread. It has three racks that come handy when you are on a baking mission. The design is elegant, and the oven is compact in size. So it will take less space on your kitchen countertop.
During the process, we also figured out that the distribution of the heat is even, and toasting is perfect from both sides. It also features a timer function and temperature control function. Both these functions are essential to get the best toasting results.

What We Like!
  • The pull-down glass door is attractive and unique.
  • To see inside the oven, it comes with a crystal clear window.
  • Easy to read digital display
  • Convection heating technology
  • Even distribution of the heat
What We Didn’t Like!
  • There is no product manual or instructions in the pack.

Buying Guide Toaster Oven

Below are some features that the best toaster oven should have. So look out for these to get the best one for your home.

Ease of Operation

Your new toaster oven should be easy and simple to use. The controls, functions, and features should be appropriately displayed, so there is less chance of pressing the wrong button. Ease of operation helps when you are using the unit for the first time. Similarly, the display and readings such as temperature levels and timers should be understandable.

Even Heating

The even heating of the toaster oven relies on several factors:
The first is a number of heating elements and how far you have placed the food from elements. There are many brands in the market that have only two heating elements. However, having two heating elements doesn’t mean that it will not work fine.
Never buy a toaster that is large in size but includes only a few heating elements. It makes no sense. Similarly, a small size toaster oven with many heating elements that can’t distribute the heat evenly is useless as well. The toaster oven with many heating elements will be expensive than others.
So here the quality wins over the quantity. Look out for those toaster ovens which have efficient heating distributing mechanism.

Reasonable Size

Toaster ovens come in various shapes and sizes. Some people prefer small ovens that are enough for small tasks like baking snacks or making toasts and cookies. While, some people like large size toaster ovens, for instance, an oven that can comfortably accommodate full chicken or a 13- inch pizza.
Large toaster ovens are difficult to move around due to their weight. Whereas compact toaster ovens are easier to move and you can store them in kitchen cabinets as well.
So, before making the final decision, figure out which size would be perfect for you and your kitchen.

Additional Features

Some simple accessories that you will find in almost all toaster ovens are racks, crumbs trays, and baking pans. There are some toaster ovens that come equipped with additional pans such as baking and broiling pans. These added features will make the work a lot easier for you.
For instance, to collect crumbs, a removable crumb tray is handy. Toaster ovens that have interior light or a timer feature are more preferred than the others. There are some other additional features that you should check out when buying your new toaster oven. These added features are pullout racks, automatic cooking mode, and time alarm.

More about Toaster Oven

Here we have compiled this list after in-depth research and after analyzing best toaster oven consumer reports. It took us more than 100 hours. Our team of experts has rated these as the best toaster ovens on multiple criteria, such as consumer reviews, reheating capabilities, and processing time. In this article, you will find the reviews of the best Toaster Oven along with other necessary details such as the buying guide, common questions about toaster ovens, and much more.

FAQ’s about Toaster Oven

What are the best Toaster Overs?

  • Breville Smart Oven Pro
  • BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Convection Countertop Toaster Oven
  • Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven
  • Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven
  • KitchenAid 12″ Convection Bake Digital Countertop Oven
  • COSORI Toaster Oven
  • Vestaware Convection Toaster Oven

Are Toaster Ovens Safe?

This is the most common question about the toaster ovens and the right question as well because it is directly related to our health. As for the risk, there are two common risks associated with these ovens; the risk of catching fire and the effects of Teflon coating.
Toaster ovens operate through heating elements. If crumbs get bunged up under the oven for a very long time, they can catch fire.
But happily, nowadays, the toaster ovens have removable crumb tray. So you can remove and wash the tray any time you want to. In this way, the risk of catching the fire is eliminated.
You might have heard about that toaster ovens are coated with Teflon. And the Teflon is not good for humans.
But the truth is all the products that contain Teflon are free of PFOA— the chemical that is not good for humans. Therefore, this concern is eliminated as well, and we can say that toaster ovens are perfectly safe for our health.
Is there any difference between a microwave and a toaster oven?
Toaster ovens are much faster than microwaves in terms of heating and efficiency. Not only this, but the toaster ovens are also used for toasting, baking, roasting, and reheating. The mechanism of the toaster oven is simple. These ovens function by using heating elements to heat the air, and this also allows for even heat distribution inside the oven.
On the other hand, the Microwave oven works through electromagnetic waves. These are only suitable for reheating purposes, not for cooking or baking tasks.

Do you need to preheat a toaster oven?

This varies from brand to brand. Usually, the preheating process of a toaster oven takes about 5 to 15 minutes to get the air hot inside the oven. But it also depends on what you are going to cook in it and on the size and capacity of the oven.

How hot does it get underneath an Oven?

The section underneath an oven is often used to keep stuff like utensils. It is hot actually very hot; that’s why no one will advise you to keep anything that can catch fire or meltdown under a toaster oven. The temperature under the oven can go as high as 200 degrees Fahrenheit.

Final Verdict

Now you have two options. If you have a limited budget, then don’t worry about the downsides of the toaster oven that you are about to purchase. The other option is to try to invest in a durable and the best toaster oven. For this option, you can check out the products that we have mentioned above and get the one that suits your needs.
As a matter of fact, it’s always better to spend your hard-earned money on a quality product because it will benefit you in the longer run. It will serve you for many years.
So, we will recommend you to go for the one that suits your needs and serve you for many years. And for this purpose, we have compiled this list as per Best Toaster Oven Consumer Reports along with detailed buying guides.
So, which toaster oven you liked that most and what you are going to cook in it? Share with us in the comment section below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top